5 STAR College Football

5 STAR College Football5 STAR College Football5 STAR College Football
  • Home
  • NFL DRAFT 2025
    • 2025 DRAFT REVIEW
    • TOP 50 OVERALL PLAYERS
    • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS QB/RB
    • '25 DRAFT RANKING WR/TE
    • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS OT/G/C
    • '25 DRAFT RANK DE/DT/NT
    • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS LB
    • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS DB's
    • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS ST
  • WEEKLY TOP 20 P5 AND G5
    • POWER 4 TOP 25 WEEK 7
    • GROUP OF 5 TOP 20 WEEK 7
  • WEEKLY GAME PICKS/REVIEW
    • PLAYOFF/BOWL WEEK 4
    • LAST WEEK
    • SEASON HISTORY
  • 2024 POWER 4 PREVIEWS
    • SEC
    • BIG TEN
    • ACC
    • BIG 12
    • PAC 2
    • 2024 INDEPENDENT PREVIEWS
  • 2024 GROUP OF 5 PREVIEWS
    • AAC
    • MOUNTAIN WEST
    • MAC
    • CONFERENCE USA
    • SUN BELT
  • PRE-SEASON DRAFT RANKINGS
    • QUARTERBACK/RUNNING BACK
    • RECIEVERS
    • OFFENSIVE LINE
    • DEFENSIVE LINE
    • LINEBACKERS
    • DEFENSIVE BACKS
    • SPECIAL TEAMS
  • FINAL TOP 25/PLAYOFFS
  • BLOGS
  • HISTORY/GAME PICKS/LINES/
  • SEASON PREDICTION HISTORY
    • SEASON PREDICTION HISTORY
  • TOP 25/PLAYOFF HISTORY
    • HISTORY
  • DRAFT HISTORY
    • 2020
    • 2021
    • 2022
    • 2023
    • 2024
  • More
    • Home
    • NFL DRAFT 2025
      • 2025 DRAFT REVIEW
      • TOP 50 OVERALL PLAYERS
      • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS QB/RB
      • '25 DRAFT RANKING WR/TE
      • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS OT/G/C
      • '25 DRAFT RANK DE/DT/NT
      • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS LB
      • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS DB's
      • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS ST
    • WEEKLY TOP 20 P5 AND G5
      • POWER 4 TOP 25 WEEK 7
      • GROUP OF 5 TOP 20 WEEK 7
    • WEEKLY GAME PICKS/REVIEW
      • PLAYOFF/BOWL WEEK 4
      • LAST WEEK
      • SEASON HISTORY
    • 2024 POWER 4 PREVIEWS
      • SEC
      • BIG TEN
      • ACC
      • BIG 12
      • PAC 2
      • 2024 INDEPENDENT PREVIEWS
    • 2024 GROUP OF 5 PREVIEWS
      • AAC
      • MOUNTAIN WEST
      • MAC
      • CONFERENCE USA
      • SUN BELT
    • PRE-SEASON DRAFT RANKINGS
      • QUARTERBACK/RUNNING BACK
      • RECIEVERS
      • OFFENSIVE LINE
      • DEFENSIVE LINE
      • LINEBACKERS
      • DEFENSIVE BACKS
      • SPECIAL TEAMS
    • FINAL TOP 25/PLAYOFFS
    • BLOGS
    • HISTORY/GAME PICKS/LINES/
    • SEASON PREDICTION HISTORY
      • SEASON PREDICTION HISTORY
    • TOP 25/PLAYOFF HISTORY
      • HISTORY
    • DRAFT HISTORY
      • 2020
      • 2021
      • 2022
      • 2023
      • 2024

5 STAR College Football

5 STAR College Football5 STAR College Football5 STAR College Football
  • Home
  • NFL DRAFT 2025
    • 2025 DRAFT REVIEW
    • TOP 50 OVERALL PLAYERS
    • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS QB/RB
    • '25 DRAFT RANKING WR/TE
    • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS OT/G/C
    • '25 DRAFT RANK DE/DT/NT
    • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS LB
    • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS DB's
    • '25 DRAFT RANKINGS ST
  • WEEKLY TOP 20 P5 AND G5
    • POWER 4 TOP 25 WEEK 7
    • GROUP OF 5 TOP 20 WEEK 7
  • WEEKLY GAME PICKS/REVIEW
    • PLAYOFF/BOWL WEEK 4
    • LAST WEEK
    • SEASON HISTORY
  • 2024 POWER 4 PREVIEWS
    • SEC
    • BIG TEN
    • ACC
    • BIG 12
    • PAC 2
    • 2024 INDEPENDENT PREVIEWS
  • 2024 GROUP OF 5 PREVIEWS
    • AAC
    • MOUNTAIN WEST
    • MAC
    • CONFERENCE USA
    • SUN BELT
  • PRE-SEASON DRAFT RANKINGS
    • QUARTERBACK/RUNNING BACK
    • RECIEVERS
    • OFFENSIVE LINE
    • DEFENSIVE LINE
    • LINEBACKERS
    • DEFENSIVE BACKS
    • SPECIAL TEAMS
  • FINAL TOP 25/PLAYOFFS
  • BLOGS
  • HISTORY/GAME PICKS/LINES/
  • SEASON PREDICTION HISTORY
    • SEASON PREDICTION HISTORY
  • TOP 25/PLAYOFF HISTORY
    • HISTORY
  • DRAFT HISTORY
    • 2020
    • 2021
    • 2022
    • 2023
    • 2024

2025 OFFENSIVE LINE TACKLES/Guards/Centers

   NUMERICAL RATINGS/DRAFT VALUE EXPLANATION LEFT TACKLES

95-100 Elite player, Yearly in All Pro debate Looking for 10/15-year career at elite level Top 2 player at position yearly. Perennial Pro Bowler. Likely Hall of Fame career. Elite at all phases, dominant in run blocking and pass protection. High character, Offensive team leader, could be team Captain no injury concerns. VERY RARE for a OG to achieve this rating.  TOP 5/10 DRAFT PICK 

90-94 Top 5/10 at the position most years, All Pro 3-5 years over career. Top 5 player at position yearly. Numerous Pro Bowls expected 10+ year career at top level. Likely a few more with another team. In HOF disscussion. Must excel at all aspects of the game, run blocking, pass protection and be elite at one, team leader, character important injury concerns must be vetted.  1st Round pick 

85-89 Solid at the position 5/8-year career at top level. Player should finish in top half of players at position most years. Perhaps a Pro Bowl or two.  Very good but only occasionally great. Looking for a player dominant as a Run blocker OR Pass blocker, Very solid and dependable player but team will be looking for replacement after about 5 years.     2nd round through Mid 3rd round 

80-84 Flaws that can be overcome/Injury concerns 4/6-year career max at best level in most cases with some patience, good coaching, and personal work ethic. Likely a quality back up/role player for several year after that, potential to become starter for few years but the team will always be looking for a better option. Often living on the bubble year to year.  Draft late 3rd/Mid 4th round 

75-79 Player developmental possibilities, with limited skills or injury concerns.  3/5 year career, one contract with drafting team,, then several years of living on the bubble. Could have great size/speeed and unrealized potential. Could carve out a longer career as a backup or special teams ace. Another reason for this rating could be major injury concerns, other reason would lack of dominant NFL skills With intense work ethic player could evolve into solid back up/special teams/role player even start.  Will play for multiple teams over career.  Draft Late 4th/5th round 

70-74  Back up /specials teams. The player could be receiving this rating due to injury concerns lack of fit or  scheme in college career or  simply lack of physical attributes.  Could develop a role and possibly into more depending on patience and work ethic. Must be a special teams ace to stick around long.   Player likely will not finish rookie contract with drafting team if it's more than 2 years. Will live  on the  bubble.  Draft 6th/7th round 

65-69 Developmental Practice squad player, The player has basic skill set needed for position,  could develop into role player with tenacity and patience, must be able to play special teams. Likely just on roster a year or two at best. 1 in 10 can beat the odds and have a longer career.  Draft late 7th round / Priority Free Agent (PFA)

60-64 Player for Training camp or Practice Squad Likely will only be active when a team desperately needs a body could be active for a couple games due to injuries. or special teams' ability. Not long for the team. Week to Week. 1 in 20 will carve out a longer career due to incredible diligence and tenacity. Likely will sign with several teams over a few years. Teams will lead these guys on often knowing they will never play a down for them. Better not completely leave school before graduation that degree will be necessary. Undrafted Free Agents only.(UDFA)

 Under 60:  Training camp body with slim hope of being more, HOPE YOU GOT YOUR DEGREE!!! THE REAL WORLD IS COMING!!!! FAST!!!!! 1 in 500 make something more of this. GM's who sign these guys for anything more than a camp body will be looking for work soon.                                                 

 EXPLANATION OF OTHER TERMS 

BUST ALERT!!! A player highly ranked by many others but one I do hold in the same regard.  Also, this term will be used for players who I call "ONE YEAR WONDERS" these players are either freakish athletes or players who had one season that FAR exceeded their previous production creating serious risk.   This term will be reserved for 1st round projections where mistakes can cripple a franchise. 

OVERRATED ALERT!!! Similar to the above but not as extreme, for after 1st/2nd rounds.. Players are not as highly rated so mistakes while still important do not carry the same weight. There are multiple reasons for this designation some but not limited to character, talent, injuries, college scheme or system.  

UNDERRATED ALERT!!! Players I feel deserve a higher ranking than many/most other so called experts.  These players in the future will be referred to as "STEALS" but I want it known my evaluation were on point when they were drafted.  

SLEEPER ALERT!!!! A player that perhaps played in a poor scheme for his talents, suffered from poor coaching, revolving door coaching, poor supporting cast but has shown flashes that can lead him to success in the proper environment. 

POSITION CHANGE ALERT!!! These are players who I feel due primarily to their skill set or more rarely at times measurables  will reach their maximum level of NFL success by changing from their primary College position.  

CHARACTER ALERT!!!  This designation is reserved for players who have had multiple issues concerning there character. This can be legal issues, multiple transfers, poor practice habits, friction with teammates and/or Coaches, Academic issues and or any other infraction that brings into question the players decision making. Teams must weigh the risk/reward related to these players VERY CAREFULLY!!   

INJURY ALERT!!!! A player with serious injury concerns, medicals vital. Possibly multiple injuries while in college or one severe injury. Also could have a long history in College and even perhaps High School "Injury Prone" is the common term.   If you are missing time on the field you are costing your team $$$$                                                                         

 2025 LEFT TACKLE OVERVIEW 

No real complete LT's available this season. Campbell has that ability but is not consistent enough to warrant the Top 10, Simmons, my other 1st rounder is coming of a serious knee injury and may not be at 100% next season but is very athletic and just starting to realize how good he could be. A couple players most will have in the 1st round, Banks, Membou can get paid well and have a career here but in my opinion, they are Guards, and I ranked them there.  I said the exact same thing about Jedrick Wills several years ago, I was right, as I will be this year. After the top 2 everyone has some holes, some see Millum at Guard, Conerly has consistency issues, Nelson is full of unrealized potential, Brown has shown flashes, Richman is underrated and very well coached. After that they are all projects and likely Back-ups or swing OL. Lundt and Grant are interesting small school prospects who with patience could surprise.

          LEFT TACKLE RANKINGS/CLASS GRADE  C-

Rank         Name        Sch         Ht      Wt      Rtg     Rnd Value 

1.Will Campbell        LSU       6-6    319       93      Mid 1st

2.Josh Simmons      OSU      6-5    317       90      Late 1st

3.Wyatt Millum        WVir       6-7    313      89       Early 2nd

4.Josh Conerly           Ore      6-5    311      86       Late 2nd

5.Jack Nelson            Wisc     6-7    314      84        Mid 3rd

6.Logan Brown           Kan     6-6    311      82        Late 3rd

7.Mason Richman    Iowa    6-6    312      81        Early 4th

8.JC Davis                      Ill         6-5    320      80        Mid 4th

9.Chase Lundt          UConn  6-8    304      78        Late 4th

10.Marques Cox           Ky       6-5    311      77        Early 5th

11.Charles Grant        W&M   6-5   311       75       Late 5th

12.Jalen Rivers          Mia(F)  6-6   319      73        Mid 6th

13.Esa Pole                 WashSt  6-5   320      72       Late 6th

14.Branson Taylor     Pitt       6-6    321      69      Early 7th

15.John Williams       Cin        6-4    320      68       PFA

16.Caleb Etienne        BYU      6-7    320      65       UDFA

17.Aiden Williams    Minn(D)6-6   314      62       UDFA

18.Carson Vinson     AlaA&M 6-7   314      60       UDFA      


   NUMERICAL RATINGS/DRAFT VALUE EXPLANATION  RIGHT TACKLES 

95-100 Elite player, Yearly in All Pro debate Looking for 10/15 year career at elite level Top 2 player at position yearly. Perennial Pro Bowler. Likely Hall of Fame career. Elite at all phases, dominant in run blocking and pass protection. High character,Offensive team leader, could be team Captain no     injury concerns. VERY RARE for a OG  to achieve this rating.  TOP 5/10 DRAFT PICK  

90-94  Top 5/10 at the position most years, All Pro 3-5 years over career. Top 5  player at position yearly. Numerous Pro Bowls expected 10+ year career at top level. Likely a few more with another team. In HOF disscussion. Must excell at all aspects of the game, run blocking, pass protection and be elite at one, team leader, character important injury concerns must be vetted.  1st Round pick 

85-89 Solid at the position 5/8-year career at top level. Player should finish in top half of players at position most years. Perhaps a Pro Bowl or two.  Very good but only occasionally great. Looking for a player dominant as a Run blocker OR Pass blocker, Very solid and dependable player but team will be looking for replacement after about 5 years.     2nd round through Mid  3rd round  

80-84  Flaws that can be overcome/Injury concerns  4/6 year career max at best level in most cases with some patience, good coaching, and personal work ethic. Likely a quality back up/role player for several year after that, potential to become starter for few years but the team will always be looking for a better option. Often living on the bubble year to year. late 3rd/Mid 4th round  

75-79 Player developmental possibilities, with limited skills or injury concerns.  3/5-year career, one contract with drafting team, then several years of living on the bubble. Could have great size/speed and unrealized potential. Could carve out a longer career as a backup or special team's ace. Another reason for this rating could be major injury concerns, other reason would lack of dominant NFL skills with intense work ethic player could evolve into solid back up/special teams/role player even start.  Will play for multiple teams over career.  Draft Mid 4th/5th round  

70-74  Back up /specials teams. The player could be receiving this rating due to injury concerns lack of fit or  scheme in college career or  simply lack of physical attributes.  Could develop a role and possibly into more depending on patience and work ethic. Must be a special teams ace to stick around long.   Player likely will not finish rookie contract with drafting team if it's more than 2 years. Will live  on the  bubble.  Draft 6th/7th round  

65-69 Developmental Practice squad player, The player has basic skill set needed for position,  could develop into role player with tenacity and patience, must be able to play special teams. Likely just on roster a year or two at best. 1 in 10 can beat the odds and have a longer career.Draft late 7th round or  Priority Free Agent  (PFA)

60-64  Player for Training camp or Practice Squad Likely will only be active when a team desperately  needs a body could be active for a couple games due to injuries. or special teams ability. Not long for the team. Week to Week. 1 in 20 will carve out a longer career due to incredible diligence and tenacity. Likely will sign with several teams over a few years. Teams will lead these guys on often knowing they will never play a down for them. Better not completely leave school before graduation that degree will be necessary. Free Agents only.  (UDFA)

Under 60 Training camp invite at best, HOPE YOU GOT YOUR DEGREE!!! THE REAL WORLD IS COMING!!!!! FAST!!!! Players with some skills or perhaps tremendous intangibles worthy of a Camp Invite, 1 in 500 make something more of this. Frankly any GM's who sign these guys for anything more than a camp body will be looking for work soon.                                                  

   EXPLANATION OF OTHER TERMS  

BUST ALERT!!! A player highly ranked by many others but one I do hold in the same regard.  Also, this term will be used for players who I call "ONE YEAR WONDERS" these players are either freakish athletes or players who had one season that FAR exceeded their previous production creating serious risk.   This term will be reserved for 1st round projections where mistakes can cripple a franchise.  

OVERRATED ALERT!!! Similar to the above but not as extreme, for after 1st/2nd rounds.. Players are not as highly rated so mistakes while still important do not carry the same weight. There are multiple reasons for this designation some but not limited to character, talent, injuries, college scheme or system.   

UNDERRATED ALERT!!! Players I feel deserve a higher ranking than many/most other so called experts.  These players in the future will be referred to as "STEALS" but I want it known my evaluation were on point when they were drafted.   

SLEEPER ALERT!!!! A player that perhaps played in a poor scheme for his talents, suffered from poor coaching, revolving door coaching, poor supporting cast but has shown flashes that can lead him to success in the proper environment.  

POSITION CHANGE ALERT!!! These are players who I feel due primarily to their skill set or more rarely at times measurables  will reach their maximum level of NFL success by changing from their primary College position.   

CHARACTER ALERT!!!  This designation is reserved for players who have had multiple issues concerning there character. This can be legal issues, multiple transfers, poor practice habits, friction with teammates and/or Coaches, Academic issues and or any other infraction that brings into question the players decision making. Teams must weigh the risk/reward related to these players. VERY CAREFULLY!!   

 INJURY ALERT!!!! A player with serious injury concerns, medicals vital. Possibly multiple injuries while in college or one severe injury. Also could have a long history in College and even perhaps High School "Injury Prone" is the common term.   If you are missing time on the field you are costing your team $$$$                                                                                                                                               

 2025 RIGHT TACKLE OVERVIEW 

A decent class of pure RT's. The top 2 Ersery, Belton definitely have long term starter potential, but NOT at LT where some idiot GM will try to stuff them. After that Jones and Corneilius both have starter ability but need some work, Truss and Trapillo need more work and are less athletic. Out of the remaining players, Pierce, Kight and Travis show the highest "sleeper" potential, both athletic, long and strong. The rest will have to work their way up from the bench.

           RIGHT TACKLE RANKINGS/CLASS GRADE C+

Rank           Name         Sch      Ht      Wt      Rtg    Rnd Value  

1.Aireontae Ersery   Minn   6-6    331       91     Late 1st

2.Anthony Belton     NCSt    6-5    336       86     Late 2nd

3.Emery Jones            LSU     6-5    315       85     Early 3rd

4.Ajani Corneilius      Ore      6-5   310       85      Early 3rd

5.Xavier Truss               Ga       6-7   309       80      Mid 4th

6.Ozzy Trapillo           BostC  6-8   316       78      Late 4th

7.John Campbell        Tenn   6-5   320       75      Late 5th

8.Hollin Pierce               Rut    6-8   341       74      Early 6th

9.Jalen Travis               IoSt     6-8   339       73      Mid 6th

10.Amari Kight              UCF    6-7   318       72     Late 6th

11.Trey Wedig                Ind      6-7   319       70     Mid 7th

12.Caleb Rogers          TxTch  6-5   312       69     Late 7th

13.B Crenshaw-Dickson Fla 6-7   316      68      Late 7th    

14.Bryce Cabledue        Kan   6-5   306      67       PFA

15.Josh Fryer                   OSU  6-6   313       65      UDFA

16.GChristian-Lightenberg OreSt 6-8 328 63  UDFA

17.Bryce Benhart           Neb   6-9   315       62       UDFA

18.Jonathan Mendoza Louis 6-8  308       60       UDFA

19.Dalton Cooper           OkSt  6-5  323        58       UDFA

20.Gerald Mincey              Ky     6-6  337       55        UDFA    

     NUMERICAL RATINGS/DRAFT VALUE EXPLANATION / GUARDS

95-100 Elite player, Yearly in All Pro debate Looking for 10/15-year career at elite level Top 2 player at position yearly. Perennial Pro Bowler. Likely Hall of Fame career. Elite at all phases, dominant in run blocking and pass protection. High character, Offensive team leader, could be team Captain no injury concerns. VERY RARE for a OG  to achieve this rating.  TOP 5/10 DRAFT PICK

90-94  Top 5/10 at the position most years, All Pro 3-5 years over career. Top 5  player at position yearly. Numerous Pro Bowls expected 10+ year career at top level. Likely a few more with another team. In HOF disscussion. Must excell at all aspects of the game, run blocking, pass protection and be elite at one, team leader, character important injury concerns must be vetted.  1st Round pick

85-89  Solid at the position 5/8 year career at top level. Player should finish in top half of players at position most years. Perhaps a Pro Bowl or two.  Very good but only occasionally great. Looking for a player dominant as a Run blocker OR Pass blocker, Very solid and dependable player but team will be looking for replacement after about 5 years.     2nd round through Mid  3rd round

80-84  Flaws that can be overcome/Injury concerns  4/6 year career max at best level in most cases with some patience, good coaching, and personal work ethic. Likely a quality back up/role player for several year after that, potential to become starter for few years but the team will always be looking for a better option. Often living on the bubble year to year.  Draft Mid 3rd/ Mid 4th round

75-79 Player developmental possibilities, with limited skills or injury concerns.  3/5 year career, one contract with drafting team,, then several years of living on the bubble. Could have great size/speeed and unrealized potential. Could carve out a longer career as a backup or special teams ace. Another reason for this rating could be major injury concerns, other reason would lack of dominant NFL skills With intense work ethic player could evolve into solid back up/special teams/role player even start.  Will play for multiple teams over career.  Draft Late 4th/5th round

70-74  Back up /specials teams. The player could be receiving this rating due to injury concerns lack of fit or  scheme in college career or  simply lack of physical attributes.  Could develop a role and possibly into more depending on patience and work ethic. Must be a special teams ace to stick around long.   Player likely will not finish rookie contract with drafting team if it's more than 2 years. Will live  on the  bubble.  Draft 6th/7th round

65-69 Developmental Practice squad player, The player has basic skill set needed for position,  could develop into role player with tenacity and patience, must be able to play special teams. Likely just on roster a year or two at best. 1 in 10 can beat the odds and have a longer career.Draft late 7th round or  Priority Free Agent  (PFA)

 60-64  Player for Training camp or Practice Squad Likely will only be active when a team desperately  needs a body could be active for a couple games due to injuries. or special teams ability. Not long for the team. Week to Week. 1 in 20 will carve out a longer career due to incredible diligence and tenacity. Likely will sign with several teams over a few years. Teams will lead these guys on often knowing they will never play a down for them. Better not completely leave school before graduation that degree will be necessary.Free Agents only.  (UDFA)

Under 60  Training camp invite at best, HOPE YOU GOT YOUR DEGREE!!! THE REAL WORLD IS COMING!!!!!!!!! Players with some skills or perhaps tremendous intangables worthy of a Camp Invite, 1 in  500 make something more of this. Frankly any GM's who sign these guys for anything more than a camp body will be looking for work soon.   


   EXPLANATION OF OTHER TERMS

BUST ALERT!!! A player highly ranked by many others but one I do hold in the same regard.  Also, this term will be used for players who I call "ONE YEAR WONDERS" these players are either freakish athletes or players who had one season that FAR exceeded their previous production creating serious risk.   This term will be reserved for 1st round projections where mistakes can cripple a franchise.

OVERRATED ALERT!!! Similar to the above but not as extreme, for after 1st/2nd rounds.. Players are not as highly rated so mistakes while still important do not carry the same weight. There are multiple reasons for this designation some but not limited to character, talent, injuries, college scheme or system. 

UNDERRATED ALERT!!! Players I feel deserve a higher ranking than many/most other so called experts.  These players in the future will be referred to as "STEALS" but I want it known my evaluation were on point when they were drafted. 

SLEEPER ALERT!!!! A player that perhaps played in a poor scheme for his talents, suffered from poor coaching, revolving door coaching, poor supporting cast but has shown flashes that can lead him to success in the proper environment.

POSITION CHANGE ALERT!!! These are players who I feel due primarily to their skill set or more rarely at times measurables  will reach their maximum level of NFL success by changing from their primary College position. 

CHARACTER ALERT!!!  This designation is reserved for players who have had multiple issues concerning there character. This can be legal issues, multiple transfers, poor practice habits, friction with teammates and/or Coaches, Academic issues and or any other infraction that brings into question the players decision making. Teams must weigh the risk/reward related to these players VERY CAREFULLY!!  

INJURY ALERT!!!! A player with serious injury concerns, medicals vital. Possibly multiple injuries while in college or one severe injury. Also could have a long history in College and even perhaps High School "Injury Prone" is the common term.   If you are missing time on the field you are costing your team $$$$       

                   

   2025 GUARD OVERVIEW    

This class has the potential to be the best Guard class in many years. The question is, will NFL execs be smart enough to realize that Banks and Membou have the talent to be ALL-PRO guards or do they want to force them to be average/decent OT's. History is not on these player's side. Without those two in the Class grade drops to a B. Jackson, a multi-year starter has been consistent, very athletic, great size and strength and unselfishly played most of this past season at LT due to injury and was excellent there, Still Guard is his home.  After that, I see at least 6 players who can be NFL starters sooner rather than later. Booker and Savaiinaea have all the tools, Gray could move inside to Center, Frazier is well coached, Williams is another OT that needs to move inside, Ratledge and Dellinger need some work. Then we have an interesting small school stud (Zabel) and several players who could develop into starters, Huber, Colby, Conner are potential "sleepers" 

                  GUARD RANKINGS/CLASS GRADE A+

Rank      Name          Sch     Ht     Wt     Rtg    Rnd Value

1.Kelvin Banks        Tex     6-4   315     94     Mid 1st

2.Donavan Jackson OSU 6-4  315     94     Mid 1st

3.Arman Membou    Mo    6-4   332     93     Mid 1st

4.Tyler Booker          Ala     6-5   321     87     Mid 2nd

5.Jonah Savaiinaea Az     6-4   324     86     Late 2nd

6.Joshua Gray        OreSt   6-5   299    83     Late 3rd

7.Miles Frazier          LSU     6-6   317    82    Late 3rd

8.Cam Williams        Tex      6-6   317    81     Early 4th

9.Tate Ratledge          Ga      6-7   308    80    Mid 4th

10.Garrett Dellinger LSU  6-4   325    78    Late 4th

11.Joe Huber               Wisc  6-5  310    77    Early 5th

12.Conner Colby        Iowa  6-6  309    77    Early 5th

13.Torrence Simpkins SCar 6-4 321   76    Mid 5th

14.Marcus MBow          Pur    6-4 303    76    Mid 5th

15.Grey Zabel               NDSt   6-6 312   75    Late 5th

16.Hayden Conner       Tex    6-6  314   73    Mid 6th

17.Dylan Fairchild          Ga    6-5  318   72    Late 6th

18.Miles Hinton             Mich  6-7  323   69    Late 7th

19.Sal Wormley         PennSt 6-3  327   69    Late 7th

20.Luke Kandra             Cin      6-5  319    67   PFA

21.Marcus Tate              Clem   6-5  321   65    UDFA

22.Jackson Slater       SacSt    6-3 311   64    UDFA

23.Luke Newman       MichSt   6-5 315   62    UDFA

        NUMERICAL RATINGS/DRAFT VALUE EXPLANATION   Centers

95-100 Elite player, Yearly in All     Pro debate Looking for 10/15 year career at elite level Top 2 player at position yearly. Perennial Pro Bowler. Likely Hall of Fame career. Elite at all phases, dominant in run blocking and pass protection. High character,Offensive team leader, could be team Captain no injury concerns. VERY RARE for a Center to achieve this rating.  TOP 5/10 DRAFT PICK

90-94  Top 5/10 at the position most years, All Pro 3-5 years over career. Top 5 player at position yearly. Numerous P ro Bowls expected, 10+ year career at top level. Likely a few more with another team. In HOF disscussion. Must excell at all aspects of the game, run blocking, pass protection and be elite at one, team leader, character important injury concerns must be vetted.  1st Round pick

85-89  Solid at the position 5/8 year career at top level. Player should finish in top half of players at position most years. Perhaps a Pro Bowl or two.  Very good but only occasionally great. Looking for a player dominant as a Run blocker OR Pass blocker, Very solid and dependable player  but team will be looking for replacement after about 5 years.     2nd round through Mid  3rd round

80-84  Flaws that can be overcome/Injury concerns  4/6 year career max at best level in most cases with some patience, good coaching, and personal work ethic. Likely a quality back up/role player for several year after that, potential to become starter for few years but the team will always be looking for a better option. Often living on the bubble year to year.  Draft Late 3rd/Mid 4th round

75-79 Player developmental possibilities, with limited skills or injury concerns.  3/5 year career, one contract with drafting team,, then several years of living on the bubble. Could have great size/speeed and unrealized potential. Could carve out a longer career as a backup or special teams ace. Another reason for this rating could be major injury concerns, other reason would lack of dominant NFL skills With intense work ethic player could evolve into solid back up/special teams/role player even start.  Will play for multiple teams over career.  Draft Late 4th/5th round

70-74  Back up /specials teams.  The player could be receiving this rating due to injury concerns lack of fit or  scheme in college career or  simply lack of physical attributes.   Could develop a role and possibly into more depending on patience and work ethic. Must be a special teams ace to stick around long.   Player likely will not finish rookie contract with drafting team if it's more than 2 years. Will live  on the  bubble.  Draft 6th/7th round

65-69 Devopmental Practice squad player,could develop into role player with tenacity and patience, must be able to play special teams. Likely just on roster a year or two at best. 1 in 50 can beat the odds and have a longer career.Draft late  7th round or  Priority Free Agent

 60-64  Player for Training camp or Practice Squad Likely will only be active when a team desperately  needs a body could be active for a couple games due to injuries. or special teams ability. Not long for the team. Week to Week. 1 in 100 will carve out a longer career due to incredible diligence and tenacity. Likely will sign with several teams over a few years. Teams will lead these guys on often knowing they will never play a down for them. Better not completely leave school before graduation that degree will be necessary.Free Agents only.

Under 60  Training camp invite at best, HOPE YOU GOT YOUR DEGREE!!! THE REAL WORLD IS COMING!!!!!!!!!  Players with some skills or perhaps tremendous intangables worthy of a Camp Invite, 1 in 500 make more of this. But frankly any GM's who sign these guys for anything more than a camp body will be looking for work soon.    


      EXPLANATION OF OTHER TERMS

BUST ALERT!!! A player highly ranked by many others but one I do hold in the same regard.  Also, this term will be used for players who I call "ONE YEAR WONDERS" these players are either freakish athletes or players who had one season that FAR exceeded their previous production creating serious risk.   This term will be reserved for 1st round projections where mistakes can cripple a franchise.

OVERRATED ALERT!!! Similar to the above but not as extreme, for after 1st round. Players are not as highly rated so mistakes while still important do not carry the same weight.   There are multiple reasons for this designation some but not limited to character, talent, injuries, college scheme or system. 

UNDERRATED ALERT!!! Players I feel deserve a higher ranking than many/most other so called experts.  These players in the future will be referred to as "STEALS" but I want it known my evaluation were on point when they were drafted. 

SLEEPER ALERT!!!! A player that perhaps played in a poor scheme for his talents, suffered from poor coaching, revolving door coaching, poor supporting cast but has shown flashes that can lead him to success in the proper environment.

POSITION CHANGE ALERT!!! These are players who I feel due primarily to their skill set or more rarely at times measurables  will reach their maximum level of NFL success by changing from their primary College position. 

CHARACTER ALERT!!!  This designation is reserved for players who have had multiple issues concerning there character. This can be legal issues, multiple transfers, poor practice habits, friction with teammates and/or Coaches, Academic issues and or any other infraction that brings into question the players decision making. Teams must weigh the risk/reward related to these players VERY CAREFULLY!!  

INJURY ALERT!!!! A player with serious injury concerns, medicals vital. Possibly multiple injuries while in college or one severe injury. Also could have a long history in College and even perhaps High School "Injury Prone" is the common term.   If you are missing time on the field you are costing your team $$$$   

       

 2025 CENTER OVERVIEW

   Depending on where they land my top 3 can all be 1st year starters, Monheim is the clear #1, McLaughlin will be hindered by injury rehab and may well slip and few rounds,  Mays is a multi-year starter.  After them, all of the rest will have to play wherever inside to get on the field, Kendall, Majors, Wilson and Cox all have starter ability but need work. And I just have a hunch that Lampkin may end up as a FB in Pittsburgh!                

          2025 CENTER RANKINGS.  CLASS GRADE B-

Rank     Name               Sch    Ht     Wt    Rtg    Rnd Value

1.Jonah Monheim     USC   6-4   302    90     Late 1st

2.Seth McLaughlin    OSU  6-4   304     86     Late 2nd

3.Cooper Mays           Tenn  6-2   305     84      Mid 3rd

4.Drew Kendall        BostC  6-4   308     80      Mid 4th

5.Jake Majors             Tex     6-3    306     79      Mid 4th

6.Jared Wilson             Ga     6-3    310     78      Late 4th

7.Eli Cox                           Ky     6-4    306      76     Mid 5th

8.Jacob Gardner       ColSt  6-4    300      74    Early 6th

9.Gus Hartwig               Pur   6-5    315      72    Late 6th

10.Weston Franklin  GaTch 6-4   310      70    Mid 7th

11.Brandon Yates       WVir   6-4   310       69   Late 7th

12.Jakai Clark               SMU   6-3  334       68    Late 7th

13.Zeke Correll            NCSt    6-3  310      67    PFA

14.Clay Webb             JackSt   6-3  310      66    PFA

15.Zach Carpenter    Mia(F)   6-4 295      65    UDFA

16.Tanner Miller        MichSt   6-1  290      60   UDFA

17.Willie Lampkin      NCar    5-10 280      55   UDFA  

,

Ravenna, Ohio 44266, United S tates

Copyright © 2025 5 Star College Football - All Rights Reserved.

Powered by